1. Quarto

    Border Worlds Star Graces New Wallpaper (February 11, 2020)

    It does! As does the Vindicator. The two main Border Worlds fighters in WC4 were really great-looking, and undoubtedly one of the reasons why most players didn't hesitate to defect at the very first opportunity. It's really unfortunate that these particular ships are never seen again anywhere...
  2. Quarto

    The 3-D Space Combat Strategizer (January 21, 2019)

    Thanks! That was both intentional, and an inevitability - you can just imagine what a mess it would have been had we somehow managed to come up with a story that makes the player the hero in this particular battle. But you will notice the player did have a name and personality, as did all the...
  3. Quarto

    The 3-D Space Combat Strategizer (January 21, 2019)

    I don't disagree that this was their objective and they achieved it well. I do however, question whether it makes sense to create a game with that objective at all. As a general rule, no one likes to feel small and irrelevant. This is certainly one of the key reasons why Freespace never became a...
  4. Quarto

    The 3-D Space Combat Strategizer (January 21, 2019)

    What? You mean you never grew to care about the pilot named Alpha One? :)
  5. Quarto

    Are there other "space carrier" novels out there with not too much "weird" elements but instead grounded military sci-fi?

    Well, I'd like to admit that, but I'd have to dig deeper into the Legends stuff to be sure. And I don't particularly want to do that ;). Oh, that wasn't what I was talking about. I meant that since Legends is a separate iteration of the Star Wars universe, where Episodes 7-9 didn't happen...
  6. Quarto

    Are there other "space carrier" novels out there with not too much "weird" elements but instead grounded military sci-fi?

    Well, there is one thing that's exceedingly impressive about Episode 9. There is something amazing about a film script that manages to start with the most horrible words that no one at all wanted to hear - and then still manage to go downhill from that low point. Surely, the words "the Emperor...
  7. Quarto

    Transmit New Poll Votes Here (January 25, 2020)

    Hmm. It is an interesting topic to consider. I'm not sure I feel strongly enough about one particular option to vote, but let me throw a few arguments in favour of three different comms. These arguments revolve mainly around three factors - utility, emotion, and satisfaction. What makes this...
  8. Quarto

    Is it possible that the confederation could have won the kilrathi war after the Battle of Earth without the Temblor Bomb or Behemoth

    I... don't think we're supposed to draw the comparison with cats quite this literally :). I can just imagine the Kilrathi formulating their strategies based on their knowledge of gorillas ("if we can identify and beat the dominant male, the rest will fall in line!" :D ).
  9. Quarto

    Dallas does it for the cash?

    That's not really true. To be precise, it's entirely false. Read through the pilot profiles in Claw Marks. Consider the new pilots we meet in WC2 and WC3 whose background we are told - for example, Shadow, Downtown, Cobra. I'd say the upper class and military families are in the minority as far...
  10. Quarto

    Take a Closer Look at WC2's Cut Carrier (January 17, 2020)

    Definitely not. Firstly, we're not making any changes at all to Standoff any more. Secondly, even if we were making changes, this change would be very exceedingly problematic. For better or worse, we chose to treat the Rigakh as a light cruiser. These stats make it a big dreadnought, which...
  11. Quarto

    Cargo Haul: Australian Kilrathi Saga Edition (January 15, 2020)

    Hmm. I posted a spare copy of the Australian Kilrathi Saga to LOAF back in the middle of 2017, and I never did hear from him whether it actually arrived or not. Given how much time has passed, and that this news item is signed by Chris, I guess it didn't. A real pity :( .
  12. Quarto

    Happy New Poll! (January 2, 2020)

    To be clear, when I say we're like a veterans' association, this is in no way meant to disparage the community. Obviously, if I had meant it in a disparaging way… I simply wouldn't be here, right? I love this community for what it is, it's just that seeing this same poll question every year...
  13. Quarto

    Happy New Poll! (January 2, 2020)

    Funny you should say that, because by odd coincidence, while I usually vote "average", this year I actually decided to vote "poor". Why? Well, I think AD's post says it all - we're deluding ourselves. Our expectations for Wing Commander have collapsed to the point where people actually think...
  14. Quarto

    WC3: what if you could win with Behemoth?

    Oh, I understand you weren't necessarily agreeing with it :). However, "school of thought" to me suggests a coherent argument. The people putting forward this theory don't have a coherent argument, they actually must intentionally ignore or reject established facts for the sake of pushing an...
  15. Quarto

    WC3: what if you could win with Behemoth?

    I think you're stretching the definition of "school of thought" a bit there :). That's definitely a case of post-hoc rationalisation, if not outright historical revisionism - the documented reality is exactly the opposite. The whole point of the concessions the US made to Russia at the Yalta...
  16. Quarto

    Freddie Prinze Jr. drops a "Kilrathi knowledge bomb"

    I really don't know about that. It seems iffy at best. There comes a point when you're showing too much. When the first trailer revealed the Emperor's voice, everyone was like, "Whoa... man, I gotta see this!" But the reason people want to see it, is because they don't get what's going on, how...
  17. Quarto

    Freddie Prinze Jr. drops a "Kilrathi knowledge bomb"

    I think there's something else here - and the underperforming Clone Wars movie you mentioned is a big hint. Looking at the numbers of all these various spin-offs, I believe Star Wars is different to the Marvel universe in that… only the fans actually care. The fanbase for Star Wars is huge. But...
  18. Quarto

    Freddie Prinze Jr. drops a "Kilrathi knowledge bomb"

    Ugh, I don't know if I really want to start a discussion around this again. But, I definitely would argue Anakin is something very, very different to Rey. I re-watched the whole series last year, and found myself really changing my mind on Anakin - and Lake Lloyd's acting, too. The thing with...
  19. Quarto

    Freddie Prinze Jr. drops a "Kilrathi knowledge bomb"

    Hey, come on, that's totally false advertising. I was expecting a Wing Commander mention in there too :). Goodness, though, for someone trying to show off his knowledge, he could use a dictionary. English is a fairly sophisticated language, he reduces it to one word. (also, he's wrong: any...
  20. Quarto

    WC3: what if you could win with Behemoth?

    In most systems of moral thought, moral acceptability does not hinge on the number of innocent victims. It's a qualitative, not a quantitative concept. Interestingly, though, WCP did backtrack a little bit towards the damage model you suggest for the temblor bomb. While in WC3 we see Kilrah...